Sarah Fisher Crumb was a member of the Philadelphia Art Alliance in the early 20th century. She was also a member of the Plastic Club, an organization whose members included Blanche Dillaye, Ellen Wetherald Ahrens, A. Margaretta Archambault, Katherine Cohen, Violet Oakley, Emily Sartain, Charlotte Harding, Margarette Lippincott, Jessie Willcox Smith, Alice Barber Stephens, and Elenore Plaisted.